Repository | Series | Book | Chapter

206026

Seeing tragedy in the news images of september 11

Wendy Bowler

pp. 85-99

Abstract

September 11, 2001, New York City: the day terrorism impresses a powerful sequence of pictures on television viewers worldwide. Leading the image assault are depictions of the World Trade Center's (WTC) Twin Towers at the moment a ball of fire erupts from one of the buildings. News reports name it a "tragedy," and it looks like one, the day's events causing suffering, death, and loss on a scarcely conceivable scale. On the newspaper front pages of September 11 and 12, what we might call the "moment of attack" appears as the dominant news picture-type, commonly at the expense of all written reportage apart from an evocative headline, sometimes only a single word.1 It is as a poster telegraphing a news-drama with many of Aristotle's components of tragedy: magnitude and gravity, completed action, an ordered sequence of events (strong plot) and spectacular effects. The fundament of tragedy in Friedrich Nietzsche's The Birth of Tragedy—Dionysian destruction, a terrible depth beneath the sphere of Apollonian surfaces, images and beauty—may also be seen to appear in the shape of the giant flames and ominous smoke.

Publication details

Published in:

Alexander Jeffrey C., Bartmański Dominik, Giesen Bernhard (2012) Iconic power: materiality and meaning in social life. Basingstoke, Palgrave Macmillan.

Pages: 85-99

DOI: 10.1057/9781137012869_6

Full citation:

Bowler Wendy (2012) „Seeing tragedy in the news images of september 11“, In: J. C. Alexander, D. Bartmański & B. Giesen (eds.), Iconic power, Basingstoke, Palgrave Macmillan, 85–99.