Repository | Journal | Volume | Article

237223

Plantinga and favorable mini-environments

T. M. Botham

pp. 431-441

Abstract

In response to a collection of essays in Jonathan Kvanvig's (1996) Warrant in Contemporary Epistemology: Essays in Honor of Plantinga's Theory of Knowledge, Alvin Plantinga notices that certain Gettier-style examples undermine his (1993b) canonical account of epistemic warrant as delineated in Warrant and Proper Function. In hopes to clarify how his account survives Gettier's purchase, he (1996; 2000) argues that a belief has warrant sufficient for knowledge only when produced in a favorable cognitive mini-environment. In Warranted Christian Belief Plantinga (2000) specifies a condition required for a cognitive mini-environment's favorability. I argue that this condition falls prey to counterexample. Then I investigate a possible solution, which I reason fails as well.

Publication details

Published in:

(2003) Synthese 135 (3).

Pages: 431-441

DOI: 10.1023/A:1023551725580

Full citation:

Botham T. M. (2003) „Plantinga and favorable mini-environments“. Synthese 135 (3), 431–441.